Review Form

1. Title of Proposed Event
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Please summarize: the topic of the workshop; its key strengths and
contributions to RSS; and any primary weaknesses or concerns: 




2. How important is this topic to the robotics community?
-------------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite important
[] not so much
[] unimportant

3. How interesting will this workshop be to RSS participants?
-------------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite interesting
[] not so much
[] uninteresting

Any comments regarding relevance or interest:



4. What is the status of the workshop website?
----------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Any comments regarding the submitted web page:



5. Is the suggested duration of the workshop appropriate?
---------------------------------------------------------

[] Yes
[] No, too long
[] No, too short


6. Do the organizers have a good plan for soliciting participation?
-----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Any comments regarding the plan for soliciting participation:



7. Have the organizers proposed a format that will encourage
discussion and interactions during their proposed event? 
-----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Any comments regarding the expected interactivity of the proposed
event: 



8. Are there an appropriate number of speakers/participants involved?
Are they relevant to the scope of the project? 
----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Any comments regarding the submitted list of speakers:



9. Have the organizers outlined how they might encourage speakers to
focus on the topic and tailor their talks to the workshop? 
-----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Any comments regarding the organizer’s plan to encourage focus on the
workshop topic? 



10. Have the organizers outlined how they will ensure diversity in
ideas and participation? 
-----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor

Please explain:



11. If outlier track: how well does the proposal push the boundaries
of traditional academic workshops by examining ideas that are (i)
important for the field; (ii) poorly treated by the formal peer-review
process? 
-----------------------------------------------------------

[] excellent
[] quite good
[] not so good
[] poor
[] not outlier track

Please provide a statement regarding how and how well the proposal
pushes the boundaries of traditional academic workshops: 



12. Main Strength/Weakness of Workshop Proposal
----------------------------------------------

+:
 
-:



Please provide feedback to the organizers on how they could improve
their event and its impact:



13. Overall Recommendation
--------------------------

[] Strong accept
[] Weak accept
[] Weak reject
[] Strong reject